The Barney Kid-songs Super-Dee-duper Super show-pilot episode

Sometime after the final Kid-songs episode (Dream on) in which Geraldo the grouchy elf had cancelled Kid Songs, Billy, having detoured to Barney's ice cream parlor on a stormy night, is in a state of depression over the new change, and tells a Godfather-like confession after he gives himself an ice cream headache after drowning his sorrows in ice cream sundaes. Inside the ice cream parlor, Barney, the proprietor of the establishment, is cleaning some plates. After flashing back to the events during and after "Dream on" Billy begins to confess, toss and turn in great stress, which gives Barney no choice but to sedate him as the scene cuts off.

As the scene returns, Barney is able to snap Billy Biggle out of his stress after sedating him and asks if he's okay. Billy replies such and tells Barney to press G7, explaining how he was performing "Head, shoulders, knees and toes" when things went rough.

Barney laughs, but Billy's angry stare quickly puts him in his tracks. After Barney tells him it wasn't his fault the photo hut mixed up his slides, Barney assures him messing up on one song isn't the end of the world. Soon after, a mysterious man in a trench coat, followed by an owl wearing a red dress and red hair, walks in. However, the man's face is obscured by the turned-up collar of his coat, before he places his briefcase on the counter. Barney then tells the man and the woman that he'll be with them in a minute before he goes back to the jukebox and pushes a few more buttons on it.

Billy is now more down than ever, which Barney admits seems to be a result of choosing the wrong song. The mysterious man is at first stern but becomes mildly sympathetic once he sees how Billy feels. Barney plays more songs on the jukebox, however, Billy is still unhappy. When Barney wants to know why Larry is so down in the dumps, the mysterious man reveals himself as Geraldo the grouchy elf, saying that he'll tell him what's going on. Billy is surprised, but also furious, that Geraldo the grouchy former Biggle-hunter elf has appeared. Geraldo approaches the jukebox and brings up the previous episode's song, which horrifies Billy.

Jimmy becomes shocked and appalled at Gerlado torture of Billy and speaks of being in the same position if he were to be stripped of his songs. Geraldo attempts to explain himself, while Barney can only give him a rather grouchy look. Geraldo opens up the briefcase that he had brought with him and reveals a petition that 167,522 fans had posted, asking that "Kid-songs" and "Barney and friends" be brought back and that Geraldo shall forgive and forget the "Dream on-last kid-songs episode" incident. Geraldo hops on the counter and elaborates that the silliness is just beginning before fainting. Picking himself back up, he tells Billy, Barney, his friends, and Hooting Annie not to be too silly. Billy is finally cheered up as Annie plays a cool song named "silly hat" on the jukebox.